Property Management on Anna Maria Island
Born from a love of the island. Built on trust.
Over a decade ago, two sisters set out to share a place that shaped their lives and their family. What began as a personal mission became one of Anna Maria Island’s most trusted names in luxury vacation rentals.
We’ve welcomed families back year after year and been there for life’s most meaningful celebrations. When back-to-back hurricanes tested the island—and us—we emerged stronger and even more committed to connecting exceptional homes with guests who will truly treasure them.
Our Results
Our properties average over 40 booked weeks annually with strong revenue performance and carefully controlled expenses. We focus on maximizing returns without layering in unnecessary fees—because our relationships with homeowners are built on trust, not transactions.
Why Homeowners Choose Us
- Boutique, not volume — We hand‑select every home. Yours won’t be one of hundreds; it will be one of our best, marketed and cared for accordingly.
- Revenue without the noise — Strong booking performance and controlled expenses, without fees that eat into your returns.
- We know your home — We learn every detail so we can guide guests with confidence and care.
- Guests who respect your property — Our luxury positioning attracts guests who value quality and treat your home as the investment it is.
- Local, always reachable — We’re on the island and resolve issues before they become problems.
- Long‑term relationships — Built on loyalty to both guests and homeowners; we’re looking for partners, not quick wins.
Discover Your Property’s True Potential
Not sure what your home could earn? Request a free rental evaluation for a clear, honest picture—no pressure, no obligation.
Request a free rental evaluation
Specialized Property Management
As a boutique agency, we curate a portfolio of high‑end vacation homes that attract discerning guests. We’ve chosen homes to suit all group sizes without compromising the high standards we hold ourselves to, earning the repeat loyalty of travelers year after year.
We work for our commission. We walk each property before and after every stay and partner with trusted, insured maintenance and cleaning teams. Our owners benefit from proven occupancy—often 40+ weeks booked annually—higher annual revenue, and lower expenses. We don’t nickel‑and‑dime.
How much can my home make?
- Slice of Paradise — 4 bedrooms, Holmes Beach — Annual revenue: $220,000
- Emerald Bay — 3 bedrooms, Holmes Beach — Annual revenue: $82,390
- Mermaid’s Crossing — 4 bedrooms, Holmes Beach — Annual revenue: $124,382
What makes us different?
Formalized in 2015 by sisters Emma and Claire after years of family vacations on Anna Maria Island, Beach Retreats grew from a passion for the island’s beauty and old‑Florida charm. After 15 years of visiting, they made the leap to call the island home—bringing personal ownership and management experience dating back to 2009.
Today, making vacation dreams come true is still our passion—and there’s no better place to do it than Anna Maria Island.
Free rental evaluation
What People are Saying
We are most thankful for Emma & Claire and the wonderful job they do to ensure that everyone’s visit is all they hoped it would be, and more! We love our little place in AMI and feel very lucky to have Beach Retreats running the show!
Mike & Debbie W — Homeowners
I have three vacation rental properties managed by Beach Retreats and have been very happy with the results. Their size allows a level of personal service to both owners and guests that larger operations lack. Their nimble marketing has maintained strong bookings.
Keith C — Homeowner
I’ve had my property with Beach Retreats for almost 3 years and couldn’t be happier. Annual rental revenue has increased ~15% year over year, with many repeat guests. The boutique feel is a world apart from the big‑box agency I used to be with.
Mike S — Homeowner
We entrusted our first Holmes Beach home to Emma and Claire in 2015 and soon moved our second property to them as well. We feel confident our guests’ needs are addressed promptly and efficiently—even when we aren’t there.
Patti H — Homeowner
I needed at least $100,000 in annual revenue to cover expenses. Two years in, my property is making $140,000. The owners are honest and trustworthy—exactly what you want when entrusting such a large investment.
Adrienne V — Homeowner
Ready to talk?
Let’s discuss your goals and create a plan for your home.
Contact us